Laura’s Post
Well, if Montgomery had built some optimism and amazement about powerful truth telling as a step towards healing, reconciliation and justice, Birmingham squelched it. Don’t get me wrong, Birmingham treated us so well: wonderful hotel, beautiful city, fantastic food (shout out to Hot and Hot Fish Club and Saw’s BBQ), but the tour of Birmingham was chilling. Red Clay Tours was absolutely outstanding, but he didn’t hold back any punches of the brutal history of this city, which earned the name “Bombingham” in the 1950’s and 1960’s, due to white supremacists preferred method of intimidation in this town.
In 3 hours he painted the unrelenting legacy of the 20th century struggle for Black freedom in Birmingham, starting in the 1920’s, when the international Communist party recognized Black Americans as an oppressed people and began organizing in places like Birmingham. The local legend here from the 1950’s is a preacher named Fred Shuttlesworth, who rejected the notion that suffering was the prescribed existence on earth and fought segregation tooth and claw. He often clashed with Dr. King, who went for more singular, strategic battles, where as Shuttlesworth felt he would settle for nothing less that the complete annihilation of segregation. This made him a target of bombings, including one that made him a legend in his community, in which a bomb as thrown essentially right outside his bedroom on Christmas night 1956, which exploded, throwing him across the room and the front of the house collapsed on top of him. He emerged from the smoking rubble of his house to the amazement of his neighbors, who then decided he was sent by divine intervention to lead them to freedom. His church pictured blow and the frame of his prior house (above), which was never repaired after the bombing.

But did freedom ever come to Birmingham? It’s a little less clear to me now. The history books will honor the hard work of those who in the Spring of 1963, organized thousands of Black children on the font-lines who went to jail by the thousands after facing dogs and fire hoses, all in a campaign to de-segregate the lunch counters of the downtown department stores, which culminated with the fall from power of the oppressive Chief of Police Bull Connor. However maybe reality is a little messier. In the wake of the 1960’s desegregation efforts, White flight from the city took much of the capitol and the city has been losing both population and economic power since then. Though its Mayor and City Council now reflect the ~ 70% Black city, their laws (including efforts to raise minimum wage and remove Confederate Statues … despite the fact that Birmingham was never a city until after the Civil War …), are crippled by the conservative (predominantly White, conservative) state legislature. It’s a state where in present day, Roy Moore, a judicial legend made famous by twice being removed from office by the Feds for first, refusing to take down a statue of the 10 commandments out of his office, and next after he was removed and then re-elected, for refusing to acknowledge marriage equality, and barely lost his 2016 Senate election by 1% to someone who had finally brought the culprits of the 1963 Birmingham Church bombing which killed 4 little girls in the 16th Street Baptist Church to justice because Moore was accused of soliciting sex from a minor. (But it all better now right? Maybe not so much … one of Alabama’s current Senators thinks the 3 branches of the Federal government are the House, the Senate and the Executive and the other proposed legislation to arrest Anthony Fauci).
Oh, and the bombings continue here. Though the last “Civil Rights” motivated bombing in Birmingham was in 1965, modern day bombings have evolved to include mail bombings of state judges and abortion clinics.
Wow, big dose of history. I’ll end it by noting that when our tour guide was probed repeatedly at the end of our tour if he has hope for Birmingham or Alabama, he said “what good thing has ever happened in Alabama from emancipation to Reconstruction to voting rights that the Federal government didn’t explicitly force Alabama to do.” He painted a picture of ravaged, poor (predominantly Black) neighborhoods for whom the good working class jobs are gone (steel) and some of whose neighborhoods are now a superfund site.
This all feels a little bit like a gut punch for anyone rooting for the underdog of justice to make a fearsome comeback in the end. But it’s that sentiment alone that gives me pause. Our guide called this out today, and it’s a theme that has been recurring on this trip: why is it that we only have tolerance for the rose-colored Hollywood fairy tale where the “good guy” wins in the end? Perhaps it’s another legacy of White supremacist thought that White people carry in this country. “Let’s not talk about that hard stuff, it’s so unpleasant …” But that is not what life is and that is not what history is. It’s brutal and it’s hard, and if we want to be part of a meaningful change we need to open our eyes, and roll up our sleeves and get right down in it. As Malcom Gladwell notes in his podcast Revisionist History, “why does everyone in this country want to remove the suffering from the story?” This does nothing to honor those who have fought and died for causes like Civil Rights and does not prepare those of us who are late to the game for the resilience we will need to carry on.
I loved everything about our Birmingham tour, even the soul shattering. And I really liked the sentiment he left us with. Asked repeatedly what he had learned in his Alabama Public Schools about this material, he deflected this saying it is not on teachers in isolation to teach this history. They’ve done the best they can with the resources given, which are never enough. He repeatedly asserted that it’s up to us to go looking for the truth. And that’s what he did in 2016, when he read the book below, “Carry Me Home” about the tortured legacy of Birmingham, information which he had never heard before, and then promptly moved home to lead tours. There is much resistance still in his city to even the existence of his tours.
But good news guys, I found the source of White Power. Let’s take it down.
A slightly less heavy aside, things that are unexpected about Alabama:
- Styrofoam lives on!
- There are vegetables here, I have confirmed it. (They are just coupled with meat)
- I see no Trump 2024 or Confederate flags anywhere (there’s more of those in Cle Elum, Washington than what I’ve seen in Alabama thus far)
- Initially put off by being everyone’s “darling,” I watched a gas station clerk “darling” everyone up and down my line, Black/White, Old/Young alike. And now I rather like it
BOOKS:
- Carry Me Home - haven’t read it, but it’s the book that caused our tour guide to quit his job in 2016 move home to Birmingham and give Civil Rights tours
PODCASTS:
- Revisionist History (by Malcolm Gladwell): The Birmingham Foot Soldier - the untold story of the famous photo and statue above (*it doesn’t end like you think it will)
- Revisionist History: State v. Johnson - this is a really intense story that involves a story about rape, so be warned if you listen. But an important hard story about how understanding where the power lies is the key to any story or history.